Where do they stand?
The Family Research Council has researched both candidates extensively, including their comments, their former votes and news reports to compile a voter scorecard on where John McCain and Barack Obama stand on family issues. It is a highly-detailed voter guide that drills down โon the issues important to the family so as to discover not only a candidate’s position, but the depth of that position.โ Footnotes and reference guides are given for further reading.
This scorecard certainly does not claim to cover every family issue, but does look at many of the ones that are or will be considered by the government. Though, in this scorecard, questions about poverty are not directly asked, by far the most significant influence on whether a child will grow up in poverty is his or her family structure. Children who grow up in intact families with married fathers and mothers are much less likely to experience poverty.
You can download a copy of this scorecard by clicking here. To see it requires a simple registration.
Here’s a sample of the questions and positions:
Women’s Health
Would you support a federal law prohibiting both human reproductive cloning and cloning for research?
McCain: Yes
Obama: No
Do you support Medicaid-funded abortions?
McCain : No
Obama : Yes.
Abstinence Education
Would you support or oppose a federal parental notification law before a minor receives an abortion?
McCain: Support
Obama : Oppose
Would you fight to protect the integrity of federally defined abstinence-until-marriage education?
McCain: Yes
Obama: No
Promoting Stronger Marriages
Do you support a U.S. constitutional amendment to define and protect marriage as the union of one man and one woman?
McCain: No
Obama: No
If you do not support a U.S. constitutional amendment to define and protect marriage now, would any of these hypothetical future circumstances allow you to support such amendment?
*if one or several state supreme courts require their states to recognize same-sex marriages from another state.
McCain: Yes
Obama: No
*if the U.S. Supreme Court requires states to recognize same-sex marriages from another state (thus overturning a provision of the federal Defense of Marriage Act)
McCain: Yes
Obama: No
*if the U.S. Supreme Court requires the federal government to recognize same-sex marriages and/or partnerships for any purpose under federal law (thus overturning a provision of the federal Defense of Marriage Act)
McCain: Yes
Obama: No
*if the U.S. Supreme Court rules that same-sex marriage is a right under the U.S. Constitution
McCain: Yes
Obama: No
The Federal Defense of Marriage Act (1996) declares marriage to be the union of one man and one woman for all purposes of the federal government and declares that states do not have to recognize same-sex marriages from other states. Which of the follow describes your position on the federal DOMA?
*I would veto any bill that would weaken any provision of the federal DOMA
McCain
*I would support repeal of the provision of DOMA that defines marriage as the union of one man and one woman for all federal purposes, thus freeing the federal government to give marital benefits to same-sex couples.
Obama
*I would support repeal of the provision of DOMA that declares states do not have to recognize same-sex marriages from other states, thus leaving courts free to require such recognition under the Constitution’s โfull faith and creditโ clause.
Homosexuality and Special Rights
Which of the following comes closest to your position on the Employment Non-Discrimination ACT (ENDA) which would grant federal civil rights protection on the basis of sexual orientation?
*I would veto any bill to provide federal civil rights protection on the basis of sexual orientation.
McCain
*I would sign a bill to give federal civil rights protection based on sexual orientation and โgender identityโ.
Obama
Which of the following comes closest to your position on the proposed federal โhate crimes law, which would allow the federal government to prosecute any โhate crimeโ anywhere in the country?
*I would veto any federal โhate crimesโ law, and leave prosecution of such cimres to state and local authorities.
McCain
*I would sign a federal hate crimes law that included protections based on sexual orientation and โgender identity.โ
Obama
Neither candidate has been aggressive in pledging to see that obscenity is prosecuted aggressively through the Department of Justice.
Another Scorecard
Another scorecard on the presidential candidates that also gives links to both the Republican and Democratic platforms is here.
Jenny Hatch
